Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Analytics

1/15/2008
07:45 AM
Connect Directly
Google+
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
100%
0%

Who Invented the Firewall?

The list of firewall 'inventors' is large and controversial. Who's really the firewall's daddy?

Nir Zuk says he developed the technology used in all firewalls today. David Pensak claims to have built the first commercially successful firewall. Marcus Ranum says his own reputation as inventor of the firewall is "marketing BS," and that David Presotto is the man. (See Ranum's Wild Security Ride.)

William Cheswick and Steven Bellovin, who literally wrote the book on firewalls in 1994 while at AT&T Bell Labs, say they didn't invent the firewall, either -- they built a circuit-level gateway and packet filtering technology.

But all of these security experts -- as well as Jeff Mogul, Paul Vixie, Brian Reid, Fred Avolio, and Brent Chapman, and others -- were associated in some way with the roots of firewall technology. Several of them have been called the father of the firewall, but most experts agree that there's not just one biological father of the technology. "There were lots of people involved in it... The idea was floating around," Ranum says.

John Pescatore, vice president and distinguished analyst at Gartner, explains it this way: "Cheswick and Bellovin were the fathers of the network firewall concept: Use packet filtering to deny all except that what is specifically allowed. Ranum was the father of the first firewall 'product' -- DEC SEAL, the open source [firewall], and the TIS Gauntlet," Pescatore says.

"And Presotto [and his colleagues] added the stateful inspection concept. Zuk was the father of the stateful firewall product at Check Point, and later pushed the appliance approach at NetScreen, so I would call him the father of the firewall appliance," Pescatore says.

The firewall's history has been well-documented, for sure, but it's tough to pinpoint just which stage of the firewall was zero day. Most security experts trace the firewall's roots, back to work done at Digital Equipment Corp. in the late 1980s by Jeff Mogul, Brian Reid, and Paul Vixie, starting with the gatekeeper.dec.com gateway, as well as to Mogul's "screend" technology.

DEC SEAL, which was shipped in 1992, was the first commercial firewall and included proxies developed by Ranum. "DEC SEAL was interesting because it had a part number and a manual and a corporation behind it," Ranum says.

During the late '80s and early '90s Cheswick, Bellovin, and company were also working on their version of the technology. "But they were building a different technology [to solve] a different problem. AT&T didn't want anything to get out," recalls Avolio, now an information assurance analyst for Johns Hopkins University's Applied Physics Lab. He says the teams from DEC and AT&T eventually did collaborate some on their research.

Meanwhile, Zuk, who helped build Check Point's firewall technology, isn't shy about taking credit for the first commercial firewall. "There is only one firewall technology in the world today -- the one that I invented. All the other guys'... work was purely academic and on paper," says Zuk, CTO of Palo Alto Networks, which sells application-aware firewalls. "Check Point's firewall was the first usable firewall that worked," he says. (See Firewalls Ready for Evolutionary Shift and Startup Puts New Spin on Firewalls.)

Then why have other security experts also been called fathers of the firewall? "Success has a lot of parents," he says.

Pensak, CTO at V.i. Labs, says there are several players besides himself who had a part in the evolution of the firewall. "Each of us had a role to play. The guys I would consider fathers on the technology end of it are Marcus Ranum, Fred Avolio," and others, he says.

Interestingly, not all of the firewall's "fathers" are big fans of the firewall anymore. Cheswick, lead member of the technical staff at AT&T Research, says he hasn't personally used a firewall since the 1990s: "They are an economic solution to weak host security. I want to see stronger host security," he says. Even so, Cheswick says the firewall still has a place -- but as "just another network element."

"The firewall as Bill and I described it in 1994 in our book is obsolete," says Bellovin, now a professor of computer science at Columbia University. Having a guard at the front door today when there are thousands of backdoors into the network just doesn't fly now, he notes. "I'm not saying get rid of it at the door. It provides a low grade of access control for low-value resources. But the real access control [should be] at the host."

Have a comment on this story? Please click "Discuss" below. If you'd like to contact Dark Reading's editors directly, send us a message.

  • Check Point Software Technologies Ltd. (Nasdaq: CHKP)
  • AT&T Research Labs
  • V.i. Laboratories Inc.

    Kelly Jackson Higgins is the Executive Editor of Dark Reading. She is an award-winning veteran technology and business journalist with more than two decades of experience in reporting and editing for various publications, including Network Computing, Secure Enterprise ... View Full Bio

    Comment  | 
    Print  | 
    More Insights
  • Comments
    Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
    Why Cyber-Risk Is a C-Suite Issue
    Marc Wilczek, Digital Strategist & CIO Advisor,  11/12/2019
    Unreasonable Security Best Practices vs. Good Risk Management
    Jack Freund, Director, Risk Science at RiskLens,  11/13/2019
    Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
    White Papers
    Video
    Cartoon Contest
    Current Issue
    Navigating the Deluge of Security Data
    In this Tech Digest, Dark Reading shares the experiences of some top security practitioners as they navigate volumes of security data. We examine some examples of how enterprises can cull this data to find the clues they need.
    Flash Poll
    Rethinking Enterprise Data Defense
    Rethinking Enterprise Data Defense
    Frustrated with recurring intrusions and breaches, cybersecurity professionals are questioning some of the industrys conventional wisdom. Heres a look at what theyre thinking about.
    Twitter Feed
    Dark Reading - Bug Report
    Bug Report
    Enterprise Vulnerabilities
    From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
    CVE-2019-14869
    PUBLISHED: 2019-11-15
    A flaw was found in all versions of ghostscript 9.x before 9.28, where the `.charkeys` procedure, where it did not properly secure its privileged calls, enabling scripts to bypass `-dSAFER` restrictions. An attacker could abuse this flaw by creating a specially crafted PostScript file that could esc...
    CVE-2019-18987
    PUBLISHED: 2019-11-15
    An issue was discovered in the AbuseFilter extension through 1.34 for MediaWiki. Once a specific abuse filter has (accidentally or otherwise) been made public, its previous versions can be exposed, thus potentially disclosing private or sensitive information within the filter's definition.
    CVE-2019-18986
    PUBLISHED: 2019-11-15
    Pimcore before 6.2.2 allow attackers to brute-force (guess) valid usernames by using the 'forgot password' functionality as it returns distinct messages for invalid password and non-existing users.
    CVE-2019-18981
    PUBLISHED: 2019-11-15
    Pimcore before 6.2.2 lacks an Access Denied outcome for a certain scenario of an incorrect recipient ID of a notification.
    CVE-2019-18982
    PUBLISHED: 2019-11-15
    bundles/AdminBundle/Controller/Admin/EmailController.php in Pimcore before 6.3.0 allows script execution in the Email Log preview window because of the lack of a Content-Security-Policy header.