Mobile Security: Why App Stores Don’t Keep Users SafeMobile Security: Why App Stores Don’t Keep Users Safe
In a preview of his Black Hat Asia Briefing next week, a security researcher offers more proof of trouble in the walled gardens of the Apple and Google App stores.
March 24, 2016
For years, users have relied on best practices to protect themselves from mobile malware. This was based on the assumption that if you download only high reputation apps from official app stores (both Google Play and the Apple App Store), you will be safe. However, this paradigm has been challenged in the passing year as more and more malicious apps infiltrate these official fortresses.
It’s a phenomenon that can no longer be ignored; malware on app stores can’t be treated as inconsequential, isolated incidents. Both Google Play and the Apple App Store have been penetrated repeatedly, exposing users to various types of malware. Even Apple advocates can no longer rely on the Apple app review process to scrutinize apps in order to protect iPhones and iPads. Let’s take a look at four apps that climbed over the Google and Apple walls and gardens.
Certifi-gate is a set of Android vulnerabilities discovered by Check Point in August 2015. These vulnerabilities enabled attackers to gain high-level privileges without the user’s consent by exploiting apps signed by OEMs. Apps which are signed by an OEM can gain privileged permissions such as screen recording and user input simulation. Check Point researchers discovered that the authentication mechanism used by these OEM signed apps can be bypassed by a malicious app, and can then be exploited in order to take control of the device.
Following the discovery, disclosure, and publication of the vulnerability, Google released a statement that Google Play doesn’t contain any malicious apps exploiting vulnerable plugins. However, two weeks after the announcement, the Check Point research team discovered a malicious app exploiting the vulnerability in order to record a device screen.
The official integrated Apple development environment is called Xcode. Cybercriminals managed to create a modified version of Xcode which was published on third-party websites. This modified Xcode version injects malicious code into every app compiled using it. These infected apps managed to bypass the Apple code review process time and again.
Though this is not the first malicious code that has managed to get into the App Store, it was one of the largest number of malicious apps to get in to date, proving that even Apple’s current review mechanism can’t secure users effectively. Just as in the Certifi-gate case, malware continued to infiltrate the App Store even after Apple knew about its existence and after it tried to block it.
In September 2015, Check Point researchers discovered a new malicious app on the Google Play store that managed to bypass Google Bouncer, Google’s app scanning mechanism, using two different components to get in.
The first and seemingly benign component is the dropper. Once installed, the dropper checks whether it’s being executed on Google’s servers and, if so, it will not execute malicious commands. Then, if installed on a user’s actual device, the dropper will download the second component to act on its malicious objective. The malicious app then continues to download fraudulent apps to generate revenue for attackers.
Sure enough, just like in the two previous cases, BrainTest returned to Google Play a few months later, this time embedded in 13 different applications. Google was yet again unable to prevent this known threat from infiltrating its protected app store.
Broken app security and verification.
Both the Apple App Store and Google Play have been infected by malware time after time. Clearly, Apple and Google are unable to cope with known malware and attack vectors, let alone new ones. Attackers continue to use the same techniques to bypass security measures successfully. Making matters worse, they’re finding new loopholes in app store defenses all the time.
Unsuspecting users who follow the recommended best practice of downloading only apps from the official app stores are still finding themselves under attack. And enterprises, like consumers, can’t afford to be vulnerable to mobile malware on their networks. One infection is all it takes to compromise sensitive business data enterprises strive so hard to protect.
In his Black Hat Asia presentation, Enterprise Apps: Bypassing the iOS Gatekeeper, Avi and co-presenter Ohad Bobrov take a deep dive into how enterprise-signed apps have been used to attack iOS devices, and offer examples of usages discovered in the wild. Click here for more about Black Hat Asia 2016, which begins next week.
About the Author(s)
You May Also Like
Hacking Your Digital Identity: How Cybercriminals Can and Will Get Around Your Authentication MethodsOct 26, 2023
Modern Supply Chain Security: Integrated, Interconnected, and Context-DrivenNov 06, 2023
How to Combat the Latest Cloud Security ThreatsNov 06, 2023
Reducing Cyber Risk in Enterprise Email Systems: It's Not Just Spam and PhishingNov 01, 2023
SecOps & DevSecOps in the CloudNov 06, 2023