Shellshocked: A Future Of ‘Hair On Fire’ BugsShellshocked: A Future Of ‘Hair On Fire’ Bugs
Most computers affected by Bash will be updated within 10 years. The rest will be vulnerable for the lifespans of all humans now living. This should concern us. But then, global warming should also concern us.
September 26, 2014
It seems that the more we integrate our lives and our national economies into the Internet, the less safe we, and our privacy, and our money, become. The human population will eventually grow weary of the endless parade of worldwide hair-on-fire technology problems like Y2K, Conficker, Heartbleed, and, as of this week, Shellshock.
By “weary” I mean thoughts like “Another day, another bug, I have no time for this, I’ll upgrade everything when I get the time.” We may already be there, given that six full years after the Conficker worm was announced, we still see about a million unique IP addresses per day in the Conficker sinkhole. Those can’t all be student researchers checking to see if the botnet still exists. Sadly, every hour of delay dramatically increases the likelihood that the device will become more deeply infected before it is patched -- after which time, patches won’t actually make anything better.
Aggregate attack surface is a progressive concept. When the total number of infected or vulnerable computers, and the total number of infections and vulnerabilities themselves, were small, the criminal miscreants of the world did not have as much free infrastructure to draw from when attacking new targets. Make no mistake, the bad guys don’t pay for hardware or connectivity -- they’re using ours instead, since ours is free, and this kind of indirection helps them hide their tracks and misdirect our investigations. Today the computational resources available to the bad guys have grown to the point where no victim is out of reach, and no attacker has to be all that frugal or even quiet about its attacks.
Shellshock is the name of a bug in “Bash,” an acronym for Bourne Again Shell, a command line interpreter present on most computers in the world except for Windows. Bash is in Linux, and Linux is in just about every embedded computer including smart TVs, smartphones and tablets, home gateways, wireless access points, Internet servers, and many industrial control systems.
There is not a quality problem with Linux per se. In fact, Linux may be the most reviewed, most tested, highest quality (per line of code) system in history. However, there’s an awful lot of code and an awful lot of interfaces -- connections between different parts of code -- and with complexity comes error just as surely as night follows day. More importantly, many devices containing Bash are not field upgradeable, either for cost reasons or because their makers died out. Even among devices that are still upgradeable, most are silent, unknown trolls in dark closets with no monitoring or auditing or management at all.
Fix they did, but…
Within a few hours of the announcement of Shellshock and the first software update to fix the bug (which fix did, by the way, turn out to be incomplete), those of us who watch the Internet for malicious activity saw hundreds of researchers scanning billions of Internet addresses, all trying to measure and catalogue attack surface.
It’s safe to assume that some of those researchers have evil intent, such as adding the vulnerable computers to a botnet, to be used later for launching DDoS attacks or similar malfeasance. And as always during times of emergency, misinformation and misunderstanding was everywhere, even in some official announcements from people and companies and agencies whose purpose in life is to keep us informed and safe against online threats.
It’s conservative to estimate that for every modern computing device we actually know is a computing device, and whose manufacturer still has the ability to update its software, there are at least 10 other computing devices that we don’t know much about, which will not have their software updated ever, and which have years or even decades of life left.
Experience tells us to expect that the computers that will be updated will be mostly updated within about 10 years. Most of the rest will be vulnerable until they die, which will take some decades, and a few million of them will still be running and still be vulnerable to Shellshock for the lifespans of all humans now living. This should concern us, but then, global warming should also concern us.
As the saying goes, “When you’re stuck in a hole, the first thing to do is stop digging.” Given the inevitability of software bugs and the growing dependence on technology for banking, communications, infrastructure, agriculture, and food supply, can we afford to continue driving innovation guided only by near-term profit, where technology’s winners are always those who pursue time-to-market over quality?
By all means, let us patch Bash wherever we can find it. But that’s busy work. The vulnerable Bash instances that we won’t find vastly outnumber those we will, and our future is going to be dominated by leftovers from an endless parade of hair-on-fire bugs that we eventually learn to live with when the next one comes along and steals our attention.
About the Author(s)
You May Also Like
Reducing Cyber Risk in Enterprise Email Systems: It's Not Just Spam and PhishingNov 01, 2023
SecOps & DevSecOps in the CloudNov 06, 2023
What's In Your Cloud?Nov 30, 2023
Everything You Need to Know About DNS AttacksNov 30, 2023
9 Traits You Need to Succeed as a Cybersecurity Leader
The Ultimate Guide to the CISSP
Quantifying the Gap Between Perceived Security and Comprehensive MITRE ATT&CK Coverage
The Cyber Threat Impact of COVID-19 to Global Business
Protecting Critical Infrastructure: The 2021 Energy, Utilities, and Industrials Cyber Threat Landscape Report