Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Operations

11/23/2016
10:00 AM
Nathan Burke
Nathan Burke
Commentary
100%
0%

Security Automation: Striking The Right Balance

What a smart toaster oven taught me about the importance of learning how to do a task versus the efficiency of automating the work.

On the train ride in this morning, I read a fascinating article that unintentionally highlighted where and when automation makes sense.

The article, This $1,500 Toaster Oven Is Everything That's Wrong With Silicon Valley Design, details a smart oven called June that uses a universe of technology to cook your food. But in attempting to cook a piece of salmon, the author finds that using automation to cook the fish just isn’t worth it.

This salmon had become more distracting to babysit than if I’d just cooked it on my own. This salmon had become a metaphor for Silicon Valley itself. Automated yet distracting. Boastful yet mediocre. Confident yet wrong. Most of all, the June is a product built less for you, the user, and more for its own ever-impending perfection as a platform. When you cook salmon wrong, you learn about cooking it right. When the June cooks salmon wrong, its findings are uploaded, aggregated, and averaged into a June database that you hope will allow all June ovens to get it right the next time. Good thing the firmware updates are installed automatically.

In the end, June – a well-intentioned piece of technology – strikes out not because of the tech, but because the problem it intends to solve isn’t really a problem that should be solved. A prerequisite to considering automation is whether the activity in question delivers incremental value each time.

When it comes to nuanced, subjective activities like cooking, playing an instrument or painting, the end result isn’t the only value produced. Mistakes are important, and the obstacles highlight the path forward. 

By the same token, when completing the same task many times with the same outcome, there’s little or no value to be derived.

A great example of this is Cujo, the home firewall that connects to every Internet-connected device on your network. Cujo automatically blocks you from visiting known malicious sites and thwarts hackers from using your IoT devices in DDoS attacks. I don’t need to know the details about my dad visiting a site known to serve malware or learn about a bot in Mongolia that is trying to log in to my printer. Instead, I’m happy with automation stopping the threat.

In every exercise, there is a balance between the utility of knowing how to do a task, and the efficiency of automating the work. Cooking a salmon well may seem difficult, but at least you learn from it and become a better cook. Cooking a salmon using June just teaches you how to cook a salmon using June. On the other hand, detecting a potential cyber threat is a numbers game. With so many different threats out there, responding to each one has little incremental value. That’s where automation makes sense.

So, when considering automation, ask yourself: Will this eliminate a task that my team can learn and grow from, or will it eliminate a task that’s making them inefficient? Finding the balance is key for effective security teams.

Related Content:

 

Nathan has written extensively about the intersection of collaboration and security, focusing on how businesses can keep information safe while accelerating the pace of sharing and collaborative action. For 10 years, Nathan has taken on marketing leadership roles in ... View Full Bio
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
97% of Americans Can't Ace a Basic Security Test
Steve Zurier, Contributing Writer,  5/20/2019
TeamViewer Admits Breach from 2016
Dark Reading Staff 5/20/2019
How a Manufacturing Firm Recovered from a Devastating Ransomware Attack
Kelly Jackson Higgins, Executive Editor at Dark Reading,  5/20/2019
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Video
Cartoon Contest
Write a Caption, Win a Starbucks Card! Click Here
Latest Comment: Could you pass the hash, I really have to use the bathroom!
Current Issue
Building and Managing an IT Security Operations Program
As cyber threats grow, many organizations are building security operations centers (SOCs) to improve their defenses. In this Tech Digest you will learn tips on how to get the most out of a SOC in your organization - and what to do if you can't afford to build one.
Flash Poll
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
CVE-2019-9892
PUBLISHED: 2019-05-22
An issue was discovered in Open Ticket Request System (OTRS) 5.x through 5.0.34, 6.x through 6.0.17, and 7.x through 7.0.6. An attacker who is logged into OTRS as an agent user with appropriate permissions may try to import carefully crafted Report Statistics XML that will result in reading of arbit...
CVE-2019-10066
PUBLISHED: 2019-05-22
An issue was discovered in Open Ticket Request System (OTRS) 7.x through 7.0.6, Community Edition 6.0.x through 6.0.17, and OTRSAppointmentCalendar 5.0.x through 5.0.12. An attacker who is logged into OTRS as an agent with appropriate permissions may create a carefully crafted calendar appointment i...
CVE-2019-10067
PUBLISHED: 2019-05-22
An issue was discovered in Open Ticket Request System (OTRS) 7.x through 7.0.6 and Community Edition 5.0.x through 5.0.35 and 6.0.x through 6.0.17. An attacker who is logged into OTRS as an agent user with appropriate permissions may manipulate the URL to cause execution of JavaScript in the context...
CVE-2019-6513
PUBLISHED: 2019-05-21
An issue was discovered in WSO2 API Manager 2.6.0. It is possible for a logged-in user to upload, as API documentation, any type of file by changing the extension to an allowed one.
CVE-2019-12270
PUBLISHED: 2019-05-21
OpenText Brava! Enterprise and Brava! Server 7.5 through 16.4 configure excessive permissions by default on Windows. During installation, a displaylistcache file share is created on the Windows server with full read and write permissions for the Everyone group at both the NTFS and Share levels. The ...