Cloud

5/30/2017
05:10 PM
Connect Directly
Google+
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
100%
0%

Bot-Driven Online Ad Fraud Losses Decline

But counterfeit ad inventory the next big worry for online advertisers.

For once, a bit of relatively good news in cybercrime: online ad fraud losses to corporate advertisers fell 10 percent this year even with an increase in digital ad spending.

That's the finding of a new study conducted by the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) and security firm White Ops, which tracked online ad traffic patterns of 49 ANA members, many of whom represent some of the nation's largest companies, as well as other digital ad activity from October 2016 through January 2017. ANA members who participated in the study include Coca Cola, Unilever, and Walmart, for example.

Online ad fraud losses for 2017 will drop to about $6.5 billion worldwide from $7.2 billion in lost revenue for corporate advertisers in 2016, the study found. Digital ad spending is forecast to increase by 10% this year, so the decline in fraud represents a positive trend in combating fraudulent bot activity, according to ANA and White Ops. ANA members overall will lose even less in revenue - some $3.3 billion worldwide, the study shows.

"This is the first year [of this study] that we have seen genuine decline" in losses to ad fraud, says Michael Tiffany, CEO of White Ops. "The cost of bot traffic that defeats detection has gone up; it used to be a fraction of a penny per visitor. Now the market price for a realistic-looking bot has risen to about a penny per visitor … It costs more to perpetuate [this crime]."

Bill Duggan, group enterprise vice president at ANA, says companies are getting savvier about online ad fraud. "Three years ago when we started this journey" to measure and prevent online ad fraud, he says, the problem was just a blip on ANA member radar screens. "Marketers are taking a bigger interest in fighting fraud" today, he says, and the data bears that out.

Criminals use bots against advertisers by giving the illusion of real ad views, and the botnet operators who run those phony website visitors make money via cash-out points.

Bots continue to look more and more like humans in order to evade detection as phony traffic. Some 75% of the fraud spotted in the study was the handiwork of a computer plus a human on the same endpoint. Meanwhile, mobile ad fraud represents a tiny portion of the fraud landscape, with under 2%, the report found.

Craig Spiezle, founder of the Online Trust Alliance, says programmatic advertising marketing may be efficient, but it comes with security and trust risks. "There's a difference between efficiency and effectiveness: yes, you sell ads quickly, and inventory is great, but effectiveness [is low] because you don't know if your ad is being viewed or seen," he says.

White Ops' Tiffany says some programmatic ad-buying operations are improving now, given the fraud problems. "Several programmatic platforms have gone above and beyond instituting new security controls to tackle the problem," he says.

The next big thing: counterfeit inventory, he says. "We are seeing an increasing amount of counterfeit inventory. That was the kind of attack that Methbot did," Tiffany says. "Not just fake visitors but entirely fake inventory that purports to be real ads running on real websites, but it exists in the ether."

Methbot was a massive online advertising fraud operation run by Russian cybercriminals that was stealing up to $5 million per day from big-name US advertisers by posing as some 6,000 major US media sites, including The Huffington Post, Fortune, ESPN, CBS Sports, and Fox News, and generating fake ad impressions. Discovered in late 2016, Methbot had been operating in plain sight for three years, using its own internal botnet infrastructure rather than than the traditional ad fraud model of infecting unsuspecting consumers to do the dirty work.

Related Content:

Kelly Jackson Higgins is Executive Editor at DarkReading.com. She is an award-winning veteran technology and business journalist with more than two decades of experience in reporting and editing for various publications, including Network Computing, Secure Enterprise ... View Full Bio

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Oldest First  |  Newest First  |  Threaded View
floydophone
50%
50%
floydophone,
User Rank: Author
5/30/2017 | 11:28:40 PM
Ad fraud is a big problem
Even though it seems to be declining, ad fraud is still a big problem. There's a lot of great coverage on the Software Engineeering Daily podcast about ad fraud and various mitigation techniques. At the end of the day, I think CPA mitigates a lot of the problem but it'll be a long time until we're fully there.
Kelly Jackson Higgins
50%
50%
Kelly Jackson Higgins,
User Rank: Strategist
5/31/2017 | 9:39:26 AM
Re: Ad fraud is a big problem
Given that losses are still in the billions of dollars, indeed it is still a huge problem. Cleaning up the pollution in the ad ecosystem entails the cooperation of all players, and continuing to make it too expensive for the bad guys to target this space.
Eduardo.Master
50%
50%
Eduardo.Master,
User Rank: Apprentice
9/7/2017 | 12:05:29 PM
Re: Ad fraud is a big problem
Can Machine Learning Help Organizations Improve Data Security?
REISEN1955
50%
50%
REISEN1955,
User Rank: Ninja
9/7/2017 | 1:15:45 PM
IBM and Watson
If I read one more post anywhere about how Watson can save every single problem in the western world through AI knoelege ..... while Lady Ginny at IBM is gutting cloud and Watson staff like crazy???    Can Watcon improve IBM revenue gone bad for 21 quarters???  AI may be great but it is NOT a total solution until itself.  Anybody remember what WOPR was and damn near did?
12 Free, Ready-to-Use Security Tools
Steve Zurier, Freelance Writer,  10/12/2018
Pair of Reports Paint Picture of Enterprise Security Struggling to Keep Up
Curtis Franklin Jr., Senior Editor at Dark Reading,  10/11/2018
New Domains: A Wide-Open Playing Field for Cybercrime
Ben April, CTO, Farsight Security,  10/9/2018
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Video
Cartoon Contest
Current Issue
Flash Poll
The Risk Management Struggle
The Risk Management Struggle
The majority of organizations are struggling to implement a risk-based approach to security even though risk reduction has become the primary metric for measuring the effectiveness of enterprise security strategies. Read the report and get more details today!
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
CVE-2018-18324
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-15
CentOS-WebPanel.com (aka CWP) CentOS Web Panel 0.9.8.480 has XSS via the admin/fileManager2.php fm_current_dir parameter, or the admin/index.php module, service_start, service_fullstatus, service_restart, service_stop, or file (within the file_editor) parameter.
CVE-2018-18322
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-15
CentOS-WebPanel.com (aka CWP) CentOS Web Panel 0.9.8.480 has Command Injection via shell metacharacters in the admin/index.php service_start, service_restart, service_fullstatus, or service_stop parameter.
CVE-2018-18323
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-15
CentOS-WebPanel.com (aka CWP) CentOS Web Panel 0.9.8.480 has Local File Inclusion via directory traversal with an admin/index.php?module=file_editor&file=/../ URI.
CVE-2018-18319
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-15
** DISPUTED ** An issue was discovered in the Merlin.PHP component 0.6.6 for Asuswrt-Merlin devices. An attacker can execute arbitrary commands because api.php has an eval call, as demonstrated by the /6/api.php?function=command&class=remote&Cc='ls' URI. NOTE: the vendor indicates that Merli...
CVE-2018-18320
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-15
** DISPUTED ** An issue was discovered in the Merlin.PHP component 0.6.6 for Asuswrt-Merlin devices. An attacker can execute arbitrary commands because exec.php has a popen call. NOTE: the vendor indicates that Merlin.PHP is designed only for use on a trusted intranet network, and intentionally allo...