Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


04:40 PM
Connect Directly

Ex-eBay CISO's Startup Aims To Beef Up Attack Information-Sharing

SecurityStarfish offers commercial service for victim companies to anonymously share breach war stories, intelligence, mitigations

The former chief information security officer at eBay has launched a new startup that offers a subscription-based service for companies hit by cyberattacks to anonymously share their war stories and obtain inside information on new attack campaigns and deflection methods.

SecurityStarfish, co-founded by David Cullinane, who served as CISO at eBay for five years, and Gordon Shevlin, former executive vice president at FishNet, emerged from stealth this week offering a commercial platform that analyzes its members' shared attack intelligence, remedies for defense, and offers heads-up attack information.

Talk of victims teaming to fight back against cyberattackers rather than going it alone began in earnest in the wake of the game-changing targeted hacks of Google, Intel, Adobe, and others in early 2010. While numerous ad-hoc and industry-specific mechanisms and groups exist for companies to swap their attack stories and intelligence, the majority of these efforts by nature are voluntary and informal. SecurityStarfish is taking that strategy to a more commercial level -- something that Cullinane, who spent years working with other companies to share their attack experiences and intelligence informally, says is key to successfully converting that information into action that helps protect those organizations from falling victim to other attacks.

[ Major global corporations call for more collaboration among organizations hit by cyberattacks, but the devil's in the details. See Victim Businesses Teaming Up To Fight Cybercriminals. ]

SecurityStarfish CEO Cullinane says during his tenure at eBay, he worked with other CSOs to share attack information on an ad-hoc basis, but in many cases, the process hit a dead end. "By the time we explained to each other what had happened, and PR, and legal" got involved, things didn't go much further, he says. "One of the problems with this is it's based on volunteer [activity]. People get busy with things, priorities shift, and [follow-up] doesn't always work."

So he spoke with some CSOs at the RSA Conference earlier this year and cemented the idea of making this attack info-sharing process a paid enterprise so it becomes a more official and regular process -- with follow-up. "We are trying to change the picture from the adversary making money ... to changing the balance of power, so to speak, by getting things done more effectively in collaboration and stop them from being able to monetize" their attacks, Cullinane says.

SecurityStarfish provides a portal to its members, which currently span Fortune companies in the financial services, manufacturing, retail, and energy industries, where they anonymously submit information and intelligence about attacks they've experienced. The company then analyzes all of the data using various tools, including Hadoop, and provides frequent reports that analyze the latest threats and provide guidance on how to remediate and protect against them.

"We give them feedback on what's happening in their vertical and cross-vertically," Cullinane says. "It's not just intelligence-gathering, aggregation, and doing the sophisticated analysis of what's happening out there." SecurityStarfish also will host working forums several times a year where member companies can share what they are doing that works in preventing attacks or mitigating threats, he says, as well as collaborate on mitigation and defense strategies.

So what does this new commercial entity mean for the ad-hoc, regional, and industry-specific attack information-sharing groups out there, including the ISACs, InfraGuards, and others?

These groups will remain key go-to places for many companies and organizations, experts say. But it's unclear in the future how organizations will select which one to go to in the aftermath of an attack if they join up with a commercial enterprise like SecurityStarfish.

"The predominant way of sharing war stories and information is to get a bunch of peers together, close the doors, and talk about it," says Wade Baker, director of risk intelligence at Verizon. "I think it's useful and serves its purposes. But when you're talking at sharing tactical-level information, you can't have a session to share that information fast enough."

Baker concurs that one of the big hurdles with ad-hoc efforts is the corporate legal department. "I think there's more recognition of the value this kind of information has, so therefore there's a greater willingness at least to look at methods of sharing this kind of intelligence responsibly," he says.

If a company shares a malware hash it found on one of itssystems that its antivirus didn't catch, that could help the rest of the community, he says. "If legal can understand what they're doing there ... and that next time [AV] will be able recognize it as badware because other organizations" shared their samples, then it could smooth the way for more sharing, he says.

Jacques Francoeur, founder and executive director of the Union of Concerned Cybersecurity Leaders (UCCL) and a former officer with the Bay Area CSO Council, says the key difference with SecurityStarfish's approach is that it formalizes a breach-information exchange. And that's a two-edged sword: "When you formalize it, you have to put in place disclosure agreements, and the formalization process, in many cases, is a path to killing the exchange [of information]. Legal does not yet appreciate the upside of sharing," he says.

Meanwhile, the informal, ad-hoc method in use today is not scalable, he says.

SecurityStarfish costs $60,000 per year, and Cullinane says his company's collaboration model is ultimately cheaper than going it alone. "The cost of doing this as an individual company that has to figure out a solution to every single attack or type of attack becomes an incredibly expensive proposition," he says. Teaming in the fight is the only way to beat the bad guys, who already collaborate among themselves, he says.

UCCL's Francoeur says the value of SecurityStarfish would come from the "actionable information" it offers its members. The catch, he says, will be what level and quality of intelligence the members provide. "And they'll have to get a critical mass so there's sufficient value to other members," he says.

Have a comment on this story? Please click "Add Your Comment" below. If you'd like to contact Dark Reading's editors directly, send us a message. Kelly Jackson Higgins is the Executive Editor of Dark Reading. She is an award-winning veteran technology and business journalist with more than two decades of experience in reporting and editing for various publications, including Network Computing, Secure Enterprise ... View Full Bio

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
When It Comes To Security Tools, More Isn't More
Lamont Orange, Chief Information Security Officer at Netskope,  1/11/2021
US Capitol Attack a Wake-up Call for the Integration of Physical & IT Security
Seth Rosenblatt, Contributing Writer,  1/11/2021
IoT Vendor Ubiquiti Suffers Data Breach
Dark Reading Staff 1/11/2021
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
2020: The Year in Security
Download this Tech Digest for a look at the biggest security stories that - so far - have shaped a very strange and stressful year.
Flash Poll
Assessing Cybersecurity Risk in Today's Enterprises
Assessing Cybersecurity Risk in Today's Enterprises
COVID-19 has created a new IT paradigm in the enterprise -- and a new level of cybersecurity risk. This report offers a look at how enterprises are assessing and managing cyber-risk under the new normal.
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
PUBLISHED: 2021-01-17
An issue was discovered in Quali CloudShell 9.3. An XSS vulnerability in the login page allows an attacker to craft a URL, with a constructor.constructor substring in the username field, that executes a payload when the user visits the /Account/Login page.
PUBLISHED: 2021-01-17
Netsia SEBA+ through 0.16.1 build 70-e669dcd7 allows remote attackers to discover session cookies via a direct /session/list/allActiveSession request. For example, the attacker can discover the admin's cookie if the admin account happens to be logged in when the allActiveSession request occurs, and ...
PUBLISHED: 2021-01-15
An issue was discovered in Malwarebytes before 4.0 on macOS. A malicious application was able to perform a privileged action within the Malwarebytes launch daemon. The privileged service improperly validated XPC connections by relying on the PID instead of the audit token. An attacker can construct ...
PUBLISHED: 2021-01-15
Docker Desktop Community before on macOS mishandles certificate checking, leading to local privilege escalation.
PUBLISHED: 2021-01-15
OneDev is an all-in-one devops platform. In OneDev before version 4.0.3, there is a critical vulnerability which can lead to pre-auth remote code execution. AttachmentUploadServlet deserializes untrusted data from the `Attachment-Support` header. This Servlet does not enforce any authentication or a...