Vulnerabilities / Threats
5/22/2014
11:40 AM
50%
50%

Flaws In EMV Chip And PIN Undercut Security

Weaknesses in the EMV protocol and implementations create vulnerabilities that could be exploited via POS malware and man-in-the-middle attacks.

10 Ways To Fight Digital Theft & Fraud
10 Ways To Fight Digital Theft & Fraud
(Click image for larger view and slideshow.)

More than one year after receiving warnings from security researchers that there are serious flaws in the EMV protocol used to authenticate credit and debit card transactions in 80 countries around the world, card issuers and ATM manufacturers have failed to patch all related flaws.

Cambridge University computer security researchers sounded that warning this week in a presentation at the IEEE Symposium on Privacy and Security in San Jose, Calif., in which they detailed two major problems with the EuroPay, MasterCard, and Visa (EMV) standard now used to secure more than 1.6 billion cards worldwide.

The researchers said they began exploring EMV security, often referred to as chip and PIN -- "in layman's terms, the chip protects against card counterfeiting, and the PIN against stolen card abuse," they explained in a related research paper -- after British bank HSBC refused to refund a series of transactions to a customer based in Malta named Mr. Gambin. During related disputed-transaction negotiations, HSBC shared detailed ATM log data with Gambin, which included the date, time, as well as an "unpredictable number" (UN), or "nonce," generated by the ATM to validate the transactions.

[Are you an eBay user? Change your password now. Read 7 Facts: eBay Fumbles Password Reset Warning.]

Reviewing the unpredictable number, however, the researchers found that it was, in fact, often predictable. "Some EMV implementers have merely used counters, timestamps or home-grown algorithms to supply this nonce," they said. "This exposes them to a 'pre-play' attack, which is indistinguishable from card cloning from the standpoint of the logs available to the card-issuing bank, and [which] can be carried out even if it is impossible to clone a card physically."

In some cases, obtaining a legitimate ATM nonce on which to base an attack would also be easy. According to the researchers, for example, the UN is printed on all receipts generated in Italy.

Digging further, the researchers also spotted a deeper flaw in the protocol that attackers could use to compromise transactions, even when an ATM generated a cryptographically strong random number. That flaw is due to the ability of attackers to intercept the unpredictable number via a man-in-the-middle attack and replace it with a different pre-computed one, which would likely pass muster with the authorizing bank. Such an attack could be executed via malware installed on POS devices, even if those devices include tamper-resistant EMV modules.

A Visa spokesman did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment about the researchers' findings.

To date, some of the random-number-generator flaws spotted by the researchers have now been patched. But the EMV alliance has yet to address the deeper flaw in the protocol itself. "The banks appear to have ignored this, perhaps reasoning that it is difficult to scale up an attack that involves access to specific physical cards and also the installation of malware or wiretaps on specific terminals," the researchers said. "We disagree. The Target compromise shows that criminals can deploy malware on merchant terminals widely and exploit it to earn serious money."

The researchers added that they know of at least one "likely case" of a related skimming attack in the wild, and warned that "the spread of ATM and POS malware is making it ever more of a threat."

In the wake of the Target breach, which occurred after attackers managed to sneak malware

Next Page

Mathew Schwartz served as the InformationWeek information security reporter from 2010 until mid-2014. View Full Bio

Previous
1 of 2
Next
Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Cartoon
Current Issue
Flash Poll
Video
Slideshows
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
CVE-2013-2184
Published: 2015-03-27
Movable Type before 5.2.6 does not properly use the Storable::thaw function, which allows remote attackers to execute arbitrary code via the comment_state parameter.

CVE-2014-3619
Published: 2015-03-27
The __socket_proto_state_machine function in GlusterFS 3.5 allows remote attackers to cause a denial of service (infinite loop) via a "00000000" fragment header.

CVE-2014-8121
Published: 2015-03-27
DB_LOOKUP in nss_files/files-XXX.c in the Name Service Switch (NSS) in GNU C Library (aka glibc or libc6) 2.21 and earlier does not properly check if a file is open, which allows remote attackers to cause a denial of service (infinite loop) by performing a look-up while the database is iterated over...

CVE-2014-9712
Published: 2015-03-27
Websense TRITON V-Series appliances before 7.8.3 Hotfix 03 and 7.8.4 before Hotfix 01 allows remote administrators to read arbitrary files and obtain passwords via a crafted path.

CVE-2015-2157
Published: 2015-03-27
The (1) ssh2_load_userkey and (2) ssh2_save_userkey functions in PuTTY 0.51 through 0.63 do not properly wipe SSH-2 private keys from memory, which allows local users to obtain sensitive information by reading the memory.

Dark Reading Radio
Archived Dark Reading Radio
Good hackers--aka security researchers--are worried about the possible legal and professional ramifications of President Obama's new proposed crackdown on cyber criminals.