Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

Threat Intelligence

New Spectre Variants Add to Vulnerability Worries

Variants 3a and 4 build on the Spectre foundation, but how worried should enterprise security professionals really be?

The Spectre and Meltdown vulnerabilities hit the most basic level of computer hardware, striking the logical interface between instruction execution and cache. Intel and operating system publishers since have released patches to remediate these two issues but the problem with the CPU architecture remains, with the addition of new vulnerabilities disclosed this week.

The newly discovered Variants 3a and 4 are the latest speculative execution vulnerabilities in Intel (and presumably AMD, ARM, and other) CPUs. These side-channel attacks exploit vulnerabilities in the basic execution of the system rather than in any piece of software. That makes them both more involved to remediate, and perfect foundations for entire families of exploits and attacks.

These latest variations on the Spectre theme were disclosed by researchers from various organizations: Jann Horn of Google Project Zero (GPZ) and Ken Johnson of the Microsoft Security Response Center (MSRC) independently discovered Variant 4, while Zdenek Sojka, Rudolf Marek and Alex Zuepke from SYSGO AG, along with Innokentiy Sennovskiy from BiZone LLC, discovered and reported Variant 3a.

Variant 4 is interesting because it could be exploited in a language-based runtime environment. These environments are typically seen in languages that are interpreted or compiled at run-time — languages like JavaScript. In most cases, these environments are encountered in Web-based applications, which is both good and bad from a Spectre vulnerability perspective.

The downside of the equation is ubiquity: it would be difficult to find a computer without one or more Web browsers in a modern enterprise. The good news, however, is every major browser has already been updated to make Spectre and its family members unavailable to attackers.

Variant 4, if successfully exploited, could allow an attacker to see into memory and access information belonging to other programs, processes, and users. Variant 3a uses the same sort of technique to a different end; in this case, an attacker could get information on the system configuration and status rather than data from any particular user.

In the case of each new variant, the organizations with the most to worry about are the same: those in the cloud. "The original worries were, 'I get a $5 account on a virtual account and I can run my code but share memory with neighbors,'" says Tod Beardsley, research director of Rapid7. "It's a real problem for the Amazons or Digital Oceans of the world."

Large cloud or hosted service providers presumably have already applied the patches provided by Intel. The existing patches for existing exploits are not what concern experts, though.

"The fact that we are seeing a new derivative of the ... Spectre vulnerabilities is not surprising. Vulnerability exploits often come in series, as we've seen with WannaCry, and later on NotPetya, both used the same SMB vulnerability to rapidly propagate across organizations," says Oren Apir, CTO of Cyberbit.

And the derivatives of Spectre will continue to be a concern because they strike at a core factor in modern computer deployment.

"We as an industry have trained people to expect speed. In this case, the vulnerabilities take advantage of the very features that make them fast," says Renaud Deraison, co-founder and CTO of Tenable. "Intel optimized for performance and later learned they were facing a tradeoff between security and performance. The vast majority of people would choose speed over security, too."

Beardsley agrees that the market is driven by a need for speed, and prioritizing performance  concerns him when the conversation turns to remediating these vulnerabilities. 

"I did see an Intel write-up where they were working to ship a fix on this but it would be shipped default 'off,'" he says. "That's a really worrisome thing because it means that no one will apply the fix. In this class of bug, where you're trading performance for security."

Trading performance for security may work in this case because while the Spectre vulnerabilities are interesting and critical, they're not being widely used for system exploits: "I can get you to run my code just by asking nicely. I don't have to be this clever," Beardsley says, pointing out that phishing and other social engineering exploits are far more economical and effective than relatively sophisticated attacks like Spectre and its kin.

Both Aspir and Beardsley expect announcements of vulnerabilities based on the Spectre and Meltdown families to continue. They say Variants 5, 6, and beyond may already be in the hands of chip and operating system vendors, waiting for the expiration of the responsible disclosure period for widespread announcement.

Beardsley sees hope, though, in the rapid evolution of the exploits. "There are super-smart people looking at the issue," Beardsley says. "It's great that we have so much runway — good guys are finding these before bad guys are using them, at least that we know of. It gives me a good feeling that the good guys are ahead of things for a change."

Related Content:

Curtis Franklin Jr. is Senior Editor at Dark Reading. In this role he focuses on product and technology coverage for the publication. In addition he works on audio and video programming for Dark Reading and contributes to activities at Interop ITX, Black Hat, INsecurity, and ... View Full Bio

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
US Turning Up the Heat on North Korea's Cyber Threat Operations
Jai Vijayan, Contributing Writer,  9/16/2019
MITRE Releases 2019 List of Top 25 Software Weaknesses
Kelly Sheridan, Staff Editor, Dark Reading,  9/17/2019
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Video
Cartoon Contest
Write a Caption, Win a Starbucks Card! Click Here
Latest Comment: "He's too shy to invite me out face to face!"
Current Issue
7 Threats & Disruptive Forces Changing the Face of Cybersecurity
This Dark Reading Tech Digest gives an in-depth look at the biggest emerging threats and disruptive forces that are changing the face of cybersecurity today.
Flash Poll
The State of IT Operations and Cybersecurity Operations
The State of IT Operations and Cybersecurity Operations
Your enterprise's cyber risk may depend upon the relationship between the IT team and the security team. Heres some insight on what's working and what isn't in the data center.
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
CVE-2019-16669
PUBLISHED: 2019-09-21
The Reset Password feature in Pagekit 1.0.17 gives a different response depending on whether the e-mail address of a valid user account is entered, which might make it easier for attackers to enumerate accounts.
CVE-2019-16656
PUBLISHED: 2019-09-21
joyplus-cms 1.6.0 allows remote attackers to execute arbitrary PHP code via /install by placing the code in the name of an object in the database.
CVE-2019-16657
PUBLISHED: 2019-09-21
TuziCMS 2.0.6 has XSS via the PATH_INFO to a group URI, as demonstrated by index.php/article/group/id/2/.
CVE-2019-16658
PUBLISHED: 2019-09-21
TuziCMS 2.0.6 has index.php/manage/notice/do_add CSRF.
CVE-2019-16659
PUBLISHED: 2019-09-21
TuziCMS 2.0.6 has index.php/manage/link/do_add CSRF.