Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


01:11 PM
Sharon Gaudin
Sharon Gaudin

Vigilante Hacker -- Hero Or Menace? Your Call…

The jury's out on a controversial hack job. Oh, one man is already going to jail in this tale. The question is whether the hacker who helped put the bad guy away was the hero of the story or just another bad guy. What's your take on this one?

The jury's out on a controversial hack job. Oh, one man is already going to jail in this tale. The question is whether the hacker who helped put the bad guy away was the hero of the story or just another bad guy. What's your take on this one?Last Friday, I wrote about a former California judge being sentenced for possession of child pornography. A 27-month sentence wrapped up the case about six years after a vigilante hacker infiltrated the judge's computer with a Trojan horse designed to weed out pedophiles.

The man going to jail is Former Orange County Superior Court Judge Ronald C. Kline, 65, of Irvine, Calif. He had pleaded guilty to four counts of possession of child pornography, admitting that the images of child porn were on his home computer, two floppy disks, and one portable disk drive.

Federal prosecutors had to traverse a bumpy road with this case, though. It was a question of how the government got the evidence on Kline, and whether it was admissible in court.

Brad Willman, a Canadian known in hacker circles as Citizen Tipster, wrote the Trojan and embedded it in images of child pornography. He then planted the images on newsgroup sites frequented by pedophiles. Once users downloaded the images, their computers would be infected by the Trojan and Willman would have access to their machines so he could root around in them, looking for other child pornography or even molestation evidence, according to Assistant U.S. Attorney Greg Staples.

Willman has not been charged for the computer break-ins, or for writing and distributing the malware.

Do you think he should have been?

According to U.S. laws (I admit I'm not all that familiar with Canadian law), what Willman did could have sunk him in a lot of legal trouble. He wrote and distributed malware. People's computers were infected. And he broke into the infected computers, invading the users' privacy.

The fact that law enforcement got the goods on Kline because of an illegal search and seizure tripped up the prosecution. One judge threw the case out, saying Willman (who actually calls himself a "hacktivist") was working as an agent of the government so the government could not benefit from his break-in. The prosecutors convinced an appeals court that the vigilante hacker was working on his own so the trial was back on. Then Kline gave up the ghost and pled guilty.

The government wouldn't have had a case without Willman and his Trojan. Rarely do we hear about a Trojan out there on the side of the angels, but because of the hacker and his Trojan, this one man will behind bars and not downloading anything.

Still, what Willman did was illegal. Government types and even one forensics investigator say if would-be do-gooder hackers begin taking up their own causes, we're going to be dealing with a heck of a mess. It's hard for forensic detectives to prove that someone, for example, downloaded child porn when there's a Trojan on the machine, opening back doors and muckin' up the works. And if hackers start attacking systems in the name of one cause or another, that is just going to litter cyberspace with more malware than we've already got now.

But I struggle to say what Willman did was wrong. On the other hand, I can see the mess that we will face if others follow in his footsteps.

So what do all of you think? Hactivists? Vigilante hackers? Are they heroes or a menace?

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
Stop Defending Everything
Kevin Kurzawa, Senior Information Security Auditor,  2/12/2020
Small Business Security: 5 Tips on How and Where to Start
Mike Puglia, Chief Strategy Officer at Kaseya,  2/13/2020
5 Common Errors That Allow Attackers to Go Undetected
Matt Middleton-Leal, General Manager and Chief Security Strategist, Netwrix,  2/12/2020
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Current Issue
6 Emerging Cyber Threats That Enterprises Face in 2020
This Tech Digest gives an in-depth look at six emerging cyber threats that enterprises could face in 2020. Download your copy today!
Flash Poll
How Enterprises Are Developing and Maintaining Secure Applications
How Enterprises Are Developing and Maintaining Secure Applications
The concept of application security is well known, but application security testing and remediation processes remain unbalanced. Most organizations are confident in their approach to AppSec, although others seem to have no approach at all. Read this report to find out more.
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
PUBLISHED: 2020-02-19
PyYAML 5.1 through 5.1.2 has insufficient restrictions on the load and load_all functions because of a class deserialization issue, e.g., Popen is a class in the subprocess module. NOTE: this issue exists because of an incomplete fix for CVE-2017-18342.
PUBLISHED: 2020-02-19
In ruamel.yaml through 0.16.7, the load method allows remote code execution if the application calls this method with an untrusted argument. In other words, this issue affects developers who are unaware of the need to use methods such as safe_load in these use cases.
PUBLISHED: 2020-02-19
A vulnerability in the Cisco ASA that could allow a remote attacker to successfully authenticate using the Cisco AnyConnect VPN client if the Secondary Authentication type is LDAP and the password is left blank, providing the primary credentials are correct. The vulnerabilities is due to improper in...
PUBLISHED: 2020-02-19
A vulnerability in Cisco Unified Communications Manager could allow an unauthenticated, remote attacker to conduct a cross-site scripting (XSS) attack on the affected software. The vulnerabilities is due to improper input validation of certain parameters passed to the affected software. An attacker ...
PUBLISHED: 2020-02-19
An issue was discovered in OpenStack Nova before 18.2.4, 19.x before 19.1.0, and 20.x before 20.1.0. It can leak consoleauth tokens into log files. An attacker with read access to the service's logs may obtain tokens used for console access. All Nova setups using novncproxy are affected. This is rel...