Dark Reading is part of the Informa Tech Division of Informa PLC

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them.Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.


06:20 PM
Thomas Claburn
Thomas Claburn
Connect Directly

Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense

Technology to help people navigate indoors is all the rage. But unless you really want to be tracked through the mall, it's largely unnecessary.

About a week ago, Apple paid an estimated $20 million for a company called WiFiSLAM that develops technology to precisely locate smartphone users indoors.

People familiar with the technology consider it the next big thing. "Indoor Location and Positioning will be huge!" declared Don Dodge, developer advocate at Google, in a blog post on Tuesday. The technology matters, he argued, "[b]ecause indoors is where we spend money, meet friends and where business happens."

As it happens, Dodge has a financial interest in the technology: He's one of several Silicon Valley entrepreneurs who invested in WiFiSLAM, according to AngelList. He said in an email that he's planning a follow-up post exploring some of the companies developing indoor location systems and that he plans to discuss his investment in WiFiSLAM and other companies then. He also said he plans to make further indoor location investments and he reiterated his enthusiasm for the field.

"I think indoor location will be big, with lots of winners," Dodge said. "Some of them will be acquired by Google, Apple, Microsoft, Samsung, and others.

"Big retailers are interested too," Dodge added. "They are further along than most people realize. The stores have SKU maps of the location of every product for inventory stocking, shelf slotting fees and other things. Games will be a big area too. Advertising by location will be big but requires enormous scale and users to work effectively."

[ What new features is Google adding to its cloud? Read Google Cloud Gets Twilio Voice, SMS. ]

Industry analysts offer a similar assessment. Forrester analyst Tony Costa calls Apple's acquisition "a game changer" because it fills a critical gap in Apple's location and mapping portfolio and because it provides the company with the means to challenge Google and Nokia, both of which have invested in indoor location tracking.

"While retail is among the first markets to embrace indoor location, its impact will be felt in every industry -- especially those with a physical presence (hospitality & travel, restaurants, entertainment & sports, etc.)," said Costa in a blog post.

And it's not just Apple, Google and Nokia. Other companies have been researching how to track people and locate them indoors, including Cisco, Microsoft, Motorola, Qualcomm, BlackBerry and Samsung, to say nothing of GPS chip makers.

Why bother? There are plenty of potential uses for indoor location tracking. As Dodge explains, the technology can be used for navigating museums, malls and other large structures; location sharing; plotting routes through store aisles; precise coupon targeting; mobile gaming; location-based advertising; business asset tracking; workforce location; and law enforcement/defense/intelligence applications.

Unfortunately, these are mostly unnecessary, at least as far as consumers are concerned.

Navigation is fundamental to existing as a functioning being in the world. For healthy, unimpaired individuals, there really should be no need to rely on a smartphone to find the most efficient route from the Jamba Juice on the north side of the mall to the Nordstroms on the south side.

As far as museums go, visitors are not perishing while trying to find a way out; they actually manage to get around just fine. Indoor location technology could probably make guided tours more precise, but it's not as if museums have no way to communicate with their visitors presently.

And airports? They're pretty well marked with signage.

In terms of location sharing, precision is generally not necessary. People have managed to meet up with friends, indoors and outdoors, since, well, pretty much all of recorded history. GPS tracking may occasionally be helpful -- shared location data could inform a party host that you're running late, for example. But a text message, email or phone call will work too, while also being more personal. And in any event, accuracy to within a meter or two is overkill for a rendezvous. Try vocal location sharing some time: "Hey, I'm over here." Or look around.

Store aisle route optimization? Once you've been to a store more than once, try remembering. Use your mind or lose it. Coupon targeting? Do you really want to be spammed by every store you walk past? Location-based advertising, meet AdBlock Plus and the power button.

About the only application I find appealing for indoor location technology is gaming. But even that shouldn't involve transmitting data to a third-party service unless absolutely necessary. Were I playing a multiplayer mobile game with someone in the vicinity, I'd want the data to travel directly between phones rather than having every player's location sent to a cloud service. Privacy matters.

But this technology isn't really for consumers. It's for businesses, so they can track you and glean more data about what you're looking at, where you're going, how long you spend in a place and so on.

I don't know about you, but this sort of thing is enough to make me enable Airplane Mode on my mobile while in the mall and pay only in cash.

In terms of asset tracking, indoor location technology seems redundant. Don't we already have RFID systems that can handle this? As for employee tracking, while I'm sure there are some reasons for doing so, I'm not sure I'd want to work for a company that did so without a really good reason.

Dodge insists the technology will be huge. But indoor spaces aren't really very big. You don't need a smartphone to find your way around in most enclosed spaces; you just need to be able-bodied and awake.

And if you do get lost, try to enjoy it -- it may not be possible a few years from now.

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
User Rank: Apprentice
4/13/2013 | 8:20:01 AM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
Your explanations are really interesting. Thank you for elucidating. Yes, there is a privacy issue when this stuff is applied to regular people and from the standpoint of the average person, such 'surveillance" is pretty scary. In the west, buildings aren't usually quite so complicated that you can't find your way around, but elsewhere in the world, i.e. Hongkong (and likely mainland China) where skyscrapers are interlinked and you walk from one building to another, to another, such an app could be very useful. The same is true in large manufacturing plants, hospitals and other institutions, like court houses. As to what commerce will do with it - with how much junk they will flood the shoppers - well, you can turn your device off while shopping.
User Rank: Apprentice
4/11/2013 | 9:08:01 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
More busy body nosy big brother spying. My GPS is always off unless I need to find someplace. Once found, it is again turned off.
User Rank: Apprentice
4/8/2013 | 8:47:52 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
Many of these same comments were made about GPS technologies when they were first being integrated into consumer devices. GPS started in the military markets where there was a compelling use case for enhancing situational awareness and improving command effectiveness - and where GPS improved safety for personnel. When location was first being architected within mobile networks (and when it then became available to mobile applications), many people underestimated its value, expressed the same privacy concerns, and ultimately underestimated the size of the consumer location market.

The US Army, DARPA, DHS, and other Government agencies have been supporting the development of infrastructure-free indoor location for several years. TRX has developed indoor location and dynamic mapping technologies for these markets to enhance situational awareness and to improve the safety of personnel that work indoors, often in dangerous environments. Within the consumer market, indoor location will deliver a clear safety benefit in dense urban environments and large buildings where GPS simply canGt return accurate information. However, there is also a clear usability benefit - location-centric applications will work better everywhere. Better usability impacts device sales, mobile subscription sales, application use, etc. ThatGs real value. (Disclosure G IGm the CEO of TRX Systems and we focus on locating, mapping, and tracking, indoors).
Thomas Claburn
Thomas Claburn,
User Rank: Ninja
4/4/2013 | 1:43:00 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
I don't doubt there are compelling vertical industry use cases. But the hype seems excessive.
User Rank: Ninja
4/3/2013 | 10:57:04 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
You are missing the point of indoor tracking. It is way more helpful to track items than people, especially in hospitals. Wheelchairs and other equipment is in limited supply and to find where items are within a large building is beneficial. Currently, that requires wiring up the entire building, doing this over small cells using existing technology and protocols is a cost savings. And after all, using a cell phone system can do more than just track stuff.
User Rank: Guru
4/3/2013 | 7:22:01 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
While it is pretty cool that they CAN do this, it doesn't meant they SHOULD. Not all ideas make money. The author makes a lot of good points against the tech and I tend to agree with him. The creepiness factor and annoyance factor would be enough to make me opt out.
User Rank: Apprentice
4/3/2013 | 4:16:21 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
I can't think of any application for this kind of technology that I would use that isn't solved by simply being able to download a floor plan to my phone. Coupon targeting sounds intriguing, but the discounts would have to be pretty good to affect my buying decision at, say, the mall, where I really only go if I have an idea of what I want to buy already.
User Rank: Apprentice
4/3/2013 | 3:19:32 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
Clearly Dodge has he own motivation for supporting it which I believe is exaggerated. That said, I can envision its application in managing students in museum or other "field trip" situations and parents following their children (Amber alert support), but plotting a course through aisles in the supermarket, puhleez , that Symantec calls me everytime I hit one of their associated websites is already sufficient cause for me to drop them.
User Rank: Apprentice
4/3/2013 | 2:06:28 PM
re: Indoor Location Tracking Has Lost Common Sense
Sometimes an idea is so ludicrous, that it doesn't really require any comments.
COVID-19: Latest Security News & Commentary
Dark Reading Staff 11/19/2020
New Proposed DNS Security Features Released
Kelly Jackson Higgins, Executive Editor at Dark Reading,  11/19/2020
How to Identify Cobalt Strike on Your Network
Zohar Buber, Security Analyst,  11/18/2020
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Cartoon Contest
Write a Caption, Win an Amazon Gift Card! Click Here
Latest Comment: A GONG is as good as a cyber attack.
Current Issue
2021 Top Enterprise IT Trends
We've identified the key trends that are poised to impact the IT landscape in 2021. Find out why they're important and how they will affect you today!
Flash Poll
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
PUBLISHED: 2020-11-23
A flaw was found in the Cephx authentication protocol in versions before 15.2.6 and before 14.2.14, where it does not verify Ceph clients correctly and is then vulnerable to replay attacks in Nautilus. This flaw allows an attacker with access to the Ceph cluster network to authenticate with the Ceph...
PUBLISHED: 2020-11-23
A flaw was found in rhacm versions before 2.0.5 and before 2.1.0. Two internal service APIs were incorrectly provisioned using a test certificate from the source repository. This would result in all installations using the same certificates. If an attacker could observe network traffic internal to a...
PUBLISHED: 2020-11-23
A flaw was found in the psql interactive terminal of PostgreSQL in versions before 13.1, before 12.5, before 11.10, before 10.15, before 9.6.20 and before 9.5.24. If an interactive psql session uses \gset when querying a compromised server, the attacker can execute arbitrary code as the operating sy...
PUBLISHED: 2020-11-23
TYPO3 is an open source PHP based web content management system. In TYPO3 from version 10.4.0, and before version 10.4.10, RSS widgets are susceptible to XML external entity processing. This vulnerability is reasonable, but is theoretical - it was not possible to actually reproduce the vulnerability...
PUBLISHED: 2020-11-23
prive/formulaires/configurer_preferences.php in SPIP before 3.2.8 does not properly validate the couleur, display, display_navigation, display_outils, imessage, and spip_ecran parameters.