In my experience, if you have one of these situations you know it. You are probably using or looking at using short stroking to address the performance issues, and at that point SSD begins to make sense, not only for performance but also for cost savings. Implementing SSD can reduce the number of physical spindles required, which saves power; it can reduce adding servers to add access bandwidth; and it can reduce the amount of time spent tuning the database that happens in these environments.
Why is this confusing? First, because the vendors getting into this space are new to it and they are trying to figure it out. In many cases some of their other solutions, like wide striping or enhanced caching techniques, may be suitable for many customers experiencing performance-related issues. As a result they are trying to figure out when to tell a customer to use wide striping or enhanced caching vs. when to use SSD. The other issue is that as most of the traditional storage manufacturers get into the space they are introducing a Flash-based SSD and in many cases are integrating it into their existing storage systems.
While Flash-based SSD is acceptable for read-heavy environments, there remains concern about reliability and the random write I/O performance, while still better than mechanical drives, may not be worth the added costs. Also by integrating Flash-based SSD into the standard storage shelves, these suppliers are exposing themselves to shelf bottleneck issues.
Shelf bottleneck issues occur because in many cases two or three flash drives can consume all the bandwidth that the current drive shelf is able to deliver, leaving 10-plus drive slots unused. Many vendors will quickly mention that these open drive slots could be used by SATA or Fiber mechanical drives, but then you may get in to speed-matching issues.
In the end, storage manufacturers will likely have to come out with specific shelves for just SSD. Probably a 1U case that only holds four SSD drives or a larger standalone system that's designed just for SSD, like those from Solid Data Systems, Texas Memory Systems, or Violin Memory. These manufacturers also provide DRAM-based SSD, which does not suffer from the write I/O or reliability concerns with Flash.
Flash is not all bad and there are some excellent uses for it, as we will discuss in our next entry.
Join us for our upcoming Webcast: Demystifying Primary Storage Data Reduction.
Track us on Twitter: http://twitter.com/storageswiss.
Subscribe to our RSS feed.
George Crump is founder of Storage Switzerland, an analyst firm focused on the virtualization and storage marketplaces. It provides strategic consulting and analysis to storage users, suppliers, and integrators. An industry veteran of more than 25 years, Crump has held engineering and sales positions at various IT industry manufacturers and integrators. Prior to Storage Switzerland, he was CTO at one of the nation's largest integrators.