Careers & People

7/26/2017
01:30 PM
Connect Directly
Twitter
Twitter
RSS
E-Mail
50%
50%

The Wild West of Security Post-Secondary Education

Black Hat researchers will show how inconsistent security schooling is at the university level.

Although an increasing number of universities and post-secondary institutions are offering some level of cybersecurity education, the discipline suffers from a lack of consistent accreditation or measurement of educational efficacy. As things stand, educators aren't carefully considering their curriculum standards and recruiters are having a hard time using scholarly credentials as a measurement for new employees.

This is the premise of a Black Hat talk by two Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT) professors who today plan to expose one of the fundamental problems behind the shortage in security talent across the industry.

They took a deep dive examining security programs across the US for their presentation. Foremost among their findings was that while most schools today use their computer science degrees as the main method for disseminating cybersecurity knowledge, the actual security content of these compsci degrees is absolutely miniscule.

The Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) curriculum guidelines that govern compsci degree accreditation only requires three to nine lecture hours of security for a four-year computer science degree, says Rob Olson, a professor of programming, mobile security, and Web app security at RIT. As he emphasizes, those aren't credit hours — those are actual hours in the classroom.

"That's not just application-level security or coding-level security. That includes, in the computing science curriculum, where networking security and strong security principals would fit in," chimes in his co-presenter, Chaim Sanders, also a professor at RIT.

The breakdown typically looks something like one hour dedicated to fundamental security, one to two lecture hours of secure design, one to two hours on defensive security, one hour on threats and attacks, and two optional hours on network security.

"And then — this is one of my favorites — one lecture hour on all of cryptography," Olson says. "And that's optional. That's optional."

Meanwhile, a number of schools are recognizing that they need to step up their game for cybersecurity and are making program changes accordingly. According to Olson and Sanders, for about 25% of schools that means specialized cybersecurity degrees. This is good in theory, but it presents problems at the execution level. First of all, some worry about whether this is even an effective method for teaching security today. While increasingly more real-world organizations move toward DevSecOps, where security is a shared discipline across the developer and operations teams, breaking it out like this goes in the opposite direction that most IT departments are moving.

"So that seems to be an interesting, although maybe not necessarily very effective, maneuver, because it separates out who will essentially become the developers from the people who are going to be doing security in organizations," says Sanders.

Meanwhile, at a more fundamental level there's no true accreditation available as a backstop for these specialized cybersecurity programs. At best, the National Security Agency (NSA) has its own set of designations that have been serving as a pseudo accreditation and which governs grants to these schools from the government for cybersecurity improvements.

"The closest thing to accreditation we have is NSA designations and in those cases there's been a lot of open-endedness historically, which has fueled a lot of fly-by-night schools that are doing it as a draw but which don't necessarily have the technical expertise to maintain the computing security program," Sanders says.

This has created a large degree of stratification of the haves and have-nots, with only the tech schools able to offer a curriculum that keeps pace with today's rapidly changing attack and defense trends. The trick is that it's difficult to even convey that to employers because there's no consistent measurement of cybersecurity educational efficacy either.

"There is very little assessment within higher education of things like learning outcomes for cybersecurity," Olson says. "The curriculum guidelines that are there say these programs are supposed to teach security, but they're not actually assessing the security knowledge that students are getting all that much."

Related Content:

 

Ericka Chickowski specializes in coverage of information technology and business innovation. She has focused on information security for the better part of a decade and regularly writes about the security industry as a contributor to Dark Reading.  View Full Bio

Comment  | 
Print  | 
More Insights
Comments
Newest First  |  Oldest First  |  Threaded View
No SOPA
50%
50%
No SOPA,
User Rank: Ninja
7/31/2017 | 2:15:43 PM
Educated on the Digital Streets
I grew up in the 80s so that meant a "security" education entailed BBS chatter, the latest issue of 2600, attending a good CON (even if it was just all locals), lots of social hacking to get library time on any system they'd let you on, walking the "digital streets" and falling, getting up and learning from your mistakes.  All the while keeping in mind that what you learned one morning might need to be discarded the next and learning something new.  And above all - no formal education.  When I see the needs in the InfoSec industry now, with all its shortages, I still feel this is the best bet for young White Hat (or Grey Hat) hopefuls.  Nothing will hold back a talented hacker more than not being able to hack freely, to build and destroy penetration labs and learn from their own mistakes, or from the knowledge of the underground.  Just the fact InfoSec education right now is considered to be a "Wild West" says it all.  Artists need freedom.  Maybe InfoSec needs some non-artists in the management roles to wrangle the wet cats, but in the end, who are these certificate programs and lengthy higher education course really designed for?  The people making all the money.  Information changes by the minute.  Exploits are born and die hourly.  there is another path to education, and it will allow you to prove yourself in measurable results.  Show me the code, somebody once said.  Talk is cheap.  And ultimately the Wild West of InfoSec education is mostly talk.

       
12 Free, Ready-to-Use Security Tools
Steve Zurier, Freelance Writer,  10/12/2018
Most IT Security Pros Want to Change Jobs
Dark Reading Staff 10/12/2018
6 Security Trends for 2018/2019
Curtis Franklin Jr., Senior Editor at Dark Reading,  10/15/2018
Register for Dark Reading Newsletters
White Papers
Video
Cartoon Contest
Write a Caption, Win a Starbucks Card! Click Here
Latest Comment: This comment is waiting for review by our moderators.
Current Issue
Flash Poll
Surviving the IT Security Skills Shortage
Surviving the IT Security Skills Shortage
Cybersecurity professionals are in high demand -- and short supply. Find out what Dark Reading discovered during their 2017 Security Staffing Survey and get some strategies for getting through the drought. Download the report today!
Twitter Feed
Dark Reading - Bug Report
Bug Report
Enterprise Vulnerabilities
From DHS/US-CERT's National Vulnerability Database
CVE-2018-10839
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-16
Qemu emulator <= 3.0.0 built with the NE2000 NIC emulation support is vulnerable to an integer overflow, which could lead to buffer overflow issue. It could occur when receiving packets over the network. A user inside guest could use this flaw to crash the Qemu process resulting in DoS.
CVE-2018-13399
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-16
The Microsoft Windows Installer for Atlassian Fisheye and Crucible before version 4.6.1 allows local attackers to escalate privileges because of weak permissions on the installation directory.
CVE-2018-18381
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-16
Z-BlogPHP 1.5.2.1935 (Zero) has a stored XSS Vulnerability in zb_system/function/c_system_admin.php via the Content-Type header during the uploading of image attachments.
CVE-2018-18382
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-16
Advanced HRM 1.6 allows Remote Code Execution via PHP code in a .php file to the user/update-user-avatar URI, which can be accessed through an "Update Profile" "Change Picture" (aka user/edit-profile) action.
CVE-2018-18374
PUBLISHED: 2018-10-16
XSS exists in the MetInfo 6.1.2 admin/index.php page via the anyid parameter.